Not too long
ago my son's cub scout den was having a sleep-over party and the big
decision to be made was which movie to watch. Each of the boys had
brought along their own favorite movies and it was up to me to decide
which ones were appropriate and which ones were not. In the pile was a
burned DVD with the hand written words "Tooth Fairy," relating to
a newly released comedy that was still in theaters but not released on
DVD as yet. All the kids knew that it was there and they all wanted to
see it. Unlike the legal gray area of fair use and making backup copies
of DVD's for the owners personal use, this one was cut and dried
illegal as the only way he could have got a hold of it was to have
copied it illegally off of the Internet or some other source.
Needless
to say I didn't let them watch the movie, and without damaging the
scout's self-esteem I made sure to turn it into a teachable moment about
how good scouts should be aware of and follow the law, even when it
comes to movies and music downloads. We even went into a short
discussion about how downloading illegal music and piracy in general
hurts other people.
The thing is, according to a
new report out this week from the US Government Accounting Office (GAO)
it appears that digital media pirates might not be the only ones that
are being dishonest. More specifically the report calls on the floor
the RIAA and MPAA for using flawed data and citing
non-existent federal studies to bolster their multi-million dollar
piracy claims.
Read more: Music and Video Piracy Studies Get Blasted By US Government